Photo by Julien L

How to deal with an EEOC retaliation charge.

 

Appearances matter, especially if the Equal Employment Opportunity Commissio (EEOC) considers you to be a hostile boss. Retaliation is historically the number one basis for charges.

Why? Employees usually complain about retaliation after they file charges of discrimination and harassment.

EEOC retaliation data

The EEOC received 88,531 total charges in 2024, and retaliation claims led at 42,301 charges. That represented about 47.8 percent of all the charges.

You might be surprised to learn most of the issues stem from withing the federal government. Retaliation is the most common issue alleged by federal employees.

Retaliation claims have climbed steadily over decades. Retaliation surpassed the 30 percent in 2007, 40 percent in 2013, and 50 percent in 2018.

 

Retaliation claims have climbed steadily over decades. Retaliation surpassed the 30 percent in 2007, 40 percent in 2013, and 50 percent in 2018.

 

Retaliation by management has long been the most-common source of legal action, according to a review of data from the EEOC.

For example, claims from 2016 to 2020:

2016 – 45.9 percent
2017 – 48.8 percent
2018 – 51.6 percent
2019 – 53.8 percent
2020 – 55.8 percent

(Data: EEOC, February 2021)

A big factor in recent years has been the so-called #MeToo movement. As a result, the most-common complaint was race discrimination until 2018 when sex discrimination surged ahead.

 

Vital Strategies to Avoid EEOC Discrimination Suits

 

Then in 2019, disability discrimination became No. 1.

Here are the actual numbers of charges that were pursued by the EEOC:

Retaliation: 37,632 – 55.8 percent
Disability: 24,324 – 36.1 percent
Race: 22,064 – 32.7 percent
Sex: 21,398 – 31.7 percent
Age: 14,183 – 21 percent
National origin: 6,377 – 9.5 percent
Color: 3,562 – 5.3 percent
Religion: 2,404 – 3.6 percent
Equal Pay Act: 980 – 1.5 percent
Genetic information: 440 – .7 percent

If combined with bias complaints, sexual harassment would have been the fifth-highest. There were 11,497 sexual harassment charges in fiscal year 2020, down slightly from the year before.

 

10 Tips on Responding to EEOC Complaint

 

The only silver lining in all of this: The majority of cases didn’t reach a courtroom. That’s because the complaints were resolved in EEOC’s conciliation procedures, which allowed companies to settle before having to go to court.

Another caution: The EEOC was victorious in 95.8 percent of discrimination and harassment complaints in federal court. Those cases netted more than $106 million for complainants – the highest number of dollars awarded since 2004.

Recommendations for employers responding to the EEOC

First of all, it might comfort you to know the EEOC is more relaxed during the Trump Administration. It’s shifted its enforcement focus away from traditional systemic and disparate impact models. It’s creating a more relaxed or altered compliance landscape for many standard employer policies.

 

First of all, it might comfort you to know the EEOC is more relaxed during the Trump Administration. It’s shifted its enforcement focus away from traditional systemic and disparate impact models.

 

Meantime, study the EEOC notice carefully. Remember an EEOC charge is a formal allegation. It isn’t a finding of guilt or a violation determination. Note the strict deadlines. They’re usually around 30 days to respond.

Notify your key stakeholders and take steps to prevent any more appearances of retaliation. Immediately alert your human resources department and legal counsel. 

Preserve all documents. Retain emails, text messages, performance reviews, witness statements, and policies that are relevant to the employee’s protected activity and the subsequent employment action.

If you believe the accusations are valid, explore mediation or resolution. The EEOC offers a voluntary, free, and confidential mediation process before launching a full investigatio. You can also consider informal settlement discussions at any point.

If you disagree, draft a factual position statement. Respond with a clear factual narrative, objective documentation, and proof of a legitimate, non-retaliatory reason. For example, provide documented performance issues or your business restructuring.

Finally, if it’s any consolation: As business-performance consultant hired by clients, such government employee claims proved to be disingenuous.

Good luck!

Conclusion

If you’re a boss, beware. Consistently making up over half of all charges: Retaliation is the most common complaint filed with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Remember an EEOC charge is only a formal allegation. Decide whether to accept the penalties or provide objective documentation to fight such allegations.

From the Coach’s Corner, to deal with other employee issues, here are valuable HR strategies:

How Your Human Resources Program Will Earn Trust — Human resources departments still aren’t trusted by many employees, according to a study by career site, Zety. This results in poor morale and productivity, turnover, lawsuits and unsatisfactory relationships with customers resulting in weaker sales. Here are six solutions.

Preventing Legal Headaches from Workplace Relationships — It used to be that consensual romantic or sexual relationships in the workplace didn’t morph into allegations of sexual harassment or favoritism. However, that’s all changed and is why many companies have prohibited consensual relationships.

Legal HR Issues? Best Practices in Workplace Investigations — As an employer, one of your biggest nightmares can be issues involving your employees. There can be many reasons to conduct an investigation. “Action expresses priorities,” said Mohandas Gandhi. So you should act quickly.

Document Employee Behavior to Withstand Legal Scrutiny — The key to documenting incidents in your workplace is to look into the future. Imagine how others will see your actions down the proverbial road. Here’s how.

Obstacles to Anticipate Before You Terminate Employees — In our litigious environment, you must prepare for several possible discrimination scenarios to overcome before starting the termination process.

“In the long run, there is not much discrimination against superior talent.”

Carter G. Woodson

__________

Author Terry Corbell has written innumerable online business-enhancement articles, and is a business-performance consultant and profit professional. Click here to see his management services. For a complimentary chat about your business situation or to schedule him as a speaker, consultant or author, please contact Terry.